What happens when a society becomes convinced that the wealthy deserve their wealth—and the poor deserve their poverty?
It begins with selfishness. But as the ancient story of Sodom illustrates, it can end somewhere far more disturbing.
The Mishnah in Pirkei Avot (5:10) describes the attitude of “What’s mine is mine, and what’s yours is yours” as characteristic of the people of Sodom. The commentator Rabbi Ovadiah of Bartenura explains that they refused to help others, even when doing so would cost them nothing.
But the Talmud (Sanhedrin 109) describes a society that went far beyond selfishness.
Sodom was an extraordinarily prosperous land. Its inhabitants believed they had everything they needed and saw no reason to welcome outsiders. They developed schemes to steal from visitors and treated the poor with shocking cruelty.
When a poor person arrived, each resident would give him a coin marked with his name, but no one would sell him food. After he starved to death, everyone would reclaim their coins.
The Talmud even tells of a young woman who was brutally killed for secretly giving bread to a poor man.
How did a seemingly reasonable attitude of “What’s mine is mine” lead to such extraordinary cruelty? Why would selfishness lead to theft, the torment of the poor, and ultimately the murder of someone for showing kindness?
The prophet Ezekiel identifies arrogance as one of Sodom’s defining sins (Ezekiel 16:49). Perhaps this holds the answer.
The people of Sodom believed that their prosperity was proof that they deserved everything they had. And if they deserved their wealth, then those who had less must be less deserving.
Why should someone else benefit from what I’ve earned, even if it costs me nothing?
From there, the thinking spiraled. Outsiders were viewed as people trying to take what they hadn’t earned. The poor were seen not as people who needed help, but as people who didn’t deserve any.
Eventually, kindness itself became a threat to their society.
When the young woman gave bread to a poor man, she wasn’t merely breaking their rules. She was challenging their entire worldview.
Her actions demonstrated that a person’s worth isn’t determined by wealth, and that someone who has nothing still deserves compassion.
If she was right, their prosperity wasn’t proof of their superiority, and their treatment of the poor was unjustified. Her simple act of kindness threatened to expose their entire philosophy as wrong.
They couldn’t tolerate that challenge, so they killed her.
What began as arrogance and selfishness developed into a society that not only refused to practice kindness, but couldn’t tolerate anyone else practicing it.
There’s an important lesson here for us.
It’s easy to look at our accomplishments and see them entirely as the product of our own hard work. And when we see someone struggling, it’s just as easy to assume they must not have worked hard enough.
But Jewish tradition teaches that everything we have is ultimately a gift from God, entrusted to us with a responsibility to help others.
The next time we encounter someone in need, rather than asking whether they deserve our help, perhaps we should ask why we’ve been given the ability to provide it.
Perhaps the reason we have what we do is precisely so that we can share it with someone who doesn’t.
